| O'Connell | | |
February 21, 2026 O'Connell 93-91 Gonzaga Gallaudet University |
| O'Connell |
February 22, 2026 O'Connell 51-57 Paul VI American University |
| Gonzaga |
| | Paul VI |
| Paul VI | February 23, 2026 Paul VI 82-76 St. John's American University |
February 21, 2026 Paul VI 62-54 McNamara Gallaudet University |
| Paul VI |
| |
| McNamara |
| |
| St. John's |
February 21, 2026 St. John's 63-49 Ireton Gallaudet University |
| St. John's |
February 22, 2026 St. John's 68-64 Carroll American University |
| Ireton |
| | St. John's |
| DeMatha | |
February 21, 2026 DeMatha 63-68 Carroll Gallaudet University |
| Carroll |
| |
| Carroll |
